I have made 2 trips to Lake Horicon, Lakehurst this year so far and will update this when i make the 3rd trip, It is great site for collecting, hiking and even just relaxing, anyway without further ado, here is a list of the species i found (and which ones i kept)
FISH
Blackbanded Sunfish (released, were found in bunches of hornwort like weeds)
Bluespotted sunfish (released)
Banded sunfish (released, found pretty much everywhere in the lake)
Mud sunfish (released, found very close to shore)
Pirate perch (kept, found one small individual in deep weed beds)
Baby Chain Pike (kept, found just under surface)
Tesselated Darter (kept, found in gravel beds and sandy areas, hardier then river populations)
Tadpole madtom (kept)
REPTILES & AMPHIBIANS
Mud turtle (released)
Snapping turtle (released)
Bullfrog tadpole (kept, found very close to shore in weed beds)
OTHER
Dragonfly Larvae (released)
Hellgramite (released)
Geese (only mentioning because they are a nuisance when using a minnow seine)
The baby pike is in a 5 gallon tank as a growout, he is eating small fish and is only 3 inches, he shares his tank with the pirate perch
The tadpoles, tessellated darters and tadpole mad tom are in my 30 gallon pond