I didn't even think of Erimyzon's, but we get oblongus larger than 5" quite frequently in large coastal plain streams.
Yeah, but if you get them as a juvenile, they're not going much larger than what Brian is describing. That size is only found in hyper-productive wild situations. I had
oblongus for 3 years and they never made it past 4".
On the other hand, the blacktail redhorse (
Moxostoma poecilurum) shot straight to 10 inches within a year and was pushing 14 inches when I donated it to the Ichthyoseum there in Hastings Michigan after three years of captive care.
So I agree with Brian's assertion that
Erimyzon is the perfect aquarium Genus for Catostomids, and is much more accepting of general conditions than some of its more picky cousins.
If you have larger tanks, don't overlook spotted sucker,
Minytrema melanops or hogsucker species,
Hypentelium. I've enjoyed success with both and they were some of my favorites I've kept along the way.
I don't know how jumprocks (
Scartomyzon)do in captivity... I'm curious to know if others have tried them, and what types of conditions / aquarium setup you tried them in or had success with them?
Regardless of species, you will want to get
the absolute smallest juvenile size you can to start with.
If you search on the Forum, I think I wrote up a more detailed sucker specific thread at one time.
Todd