AH HA! (Smacks forehead) That's it! Thank you!
I took that fish out of its tank last night and moved it in with my other madtoms. I also have two brindleds and a tadpole madtom that reputable NANFA members identified (not ignorant ones like me). When I caught the fish, I thought it was a brindled, then later I thought it was a tadpole. When I put it next to my real tadpole madtom, they didn't look the same.
Right now the stonecat is about the same size as my real tadpole madtom. I thought it grew awfully fast. Now I know that it's still growing. I have plenty of crayfish, I won't miss one. The fish that have been disappearing, however, I do miss. At least that will stop now.