Haha. Certainly not that cold...but maybe something that would be ok going into the 50's?Obviously you hadn't been abusing them enough over the summer to get them ready.
I have some feeder guppies running around in assorted boxes here and water dipping down to the 60's and below has caused large losses of the adults. Curiously, the fry seem unaffected.
Might Heterandria formosa make a better coldwater feeder? I recall they bred quite slowly in comparison...but at least they are not cannibals like Gambusia are.